Spain’s “Google Tax” Highlights Europe’s Protectionist Approach to Innovative Technologies

 

Google Spain

Last week, the Cortes Generales and President of Spain passed a law that would force search engines like Google to pay newpapers, magazines and other periodical sites in Spain’s newspaper association for linking directly to their content in search results.

The Canon AEDE law (Spanish) is a part of Spain’s copyright reform proposal supported by Spain’s newspaper lobby, the Asociation de Editors de Diarios Espanioles (“AEDE”). The law is effectively a Linking Tax that seeks to subsidize losses that newspapers have suffered from the rise of the Web. Canon AEDE “protects” the intellectual property of Spain’s periodicals in the form of a fee that periodicals  charge to Google and other content aggregators for listing their sites within their news search results.

To be clear: The law focuses on Google News and other aggregator results rather than general keyword searches. It could, however also have a significant effect on User-Generated-Content sites like Twitter and Facebook, which are also adept at both sharing and contextualizing news links.

With the New York Times reporting earlier today that despite gains in overall circulation, it’s profits have fallen by 21%, Spain’s new law presents a monetization scheme that content sites around the world would appreciate, but it may create more problems than it solves.

The first issue is that the mechanism of these payments is murky. The law calls for Google and other content aggregators to pay publications a fee to “periodically update their links,” (paraphrase) which, in many cases ignores the means by which links appear as the result of searches or content aggregator algorithms. More important, is the way that Canon AEDE, which derives its authority from copyright law, disregards the doctrine of Fair Use; a common system of rules which allows individuals and organizations to paraphrase and reference content for informational purposes.

In recent years, the people and government of Spain have been no stranger to legal controversies surrounding search engines using Google specifically as a target. Earlier this year the EU Commission ruled that, based on a Spanish complaint, Google and other search engines must allow for the “Right to be Forgotten,” which means providing users with a means to request the removal of any search result which involves their personal activities. There too, the Europeans failed to provide any specific instructions, leaving Google, Microsoft and other search engines to develop concrete solutions to abide by these laws.

Spain has also challenged smaller US tech firms whose innovations are focused on the disruptive sharing economy.At the behest of hotel lobbyists, the Spanish government is cracking down on Air BnB and Uber by fining them as much as $40,000 in some instances due to not reporting their activity to the Spanish Tourism board.

Indeed recently Google and other technology companies are seemingly under constant attack by Europe’s drive to curb the cultural influence of the Internet and draw revenue from disruptive American technology products and services.

In 2013 the French Superior Council of Audio Visual has also proposed that Facebook and Youtube should pay a tax based on the ad revenue gained from French traffic to finance French cultural products. In addition to the proposed content-based tax revenue, French authorities are exploring ways to to further cash in on the success of American technology giants by imposing an added tax on devices like smartphones and tablets running operating systems built by Apple and Google. These revenues, they propose, would also finance French cultural products.

Germany’s Bundesregierung  passed a law similar to Canon AEDE in late March of 2013. Google’s response was to remove the content provided by Germany’s periodicals from Google News. Google then allowed each affected website to re-enlist on Google News if and only if they waived their right to collect the very fees the German law said they were entitled to.

Julio Alonso reports that Canon AEDE attempts to block Google’s Germany strategy by stating that the fees are an “inalienable right,” which means that editors cannot opt-out or refuse to collect the fees. The law also proposes the creation of an industry organization whose sole responsibility is to collect these fees from Google and other aggregators.

The internal controversy surrounding Canon AEDE was considerable. Genbeta.com reports that opposition to the law within the Cortes Generales proposed as many as 169 partial amendments though it remains unclear as to which of these amendments were accepted before Canon AEDE was signed into law.

It’s easy to see the motivation behind Canon AEDE. From the perspective of AEDE, the trade group that is the law’s namesake, Google’s ability to generate advertising revenue from searches of their content is problematic. It’s also worthy to note that Spain, which is Europe’s 4th largest economy, is pulling itself out of a six year economic slump. With an unemployment rate at one quarter of the Spanish workforce, the Cortes Generales and the President hope that the estimated €1.13 billion in revenues from fees and fines associated with Canon AEDE could get more of Spain’s young people working while also coming across as a populist win.

The law is set to go into effect in late 2014.

The Drill Down 333: Two-Faced (preview)

fb-mood

This week, Google buys into music and shuts down their oldest social network, Did T-Mobile swindle customers out of millions of hidden fees?, Facebook’s secret mood manipulation study, and is the NSA’s first transparency report just one big oxymoron?

See the full post here on Geeks of Doom!

Subscribe!

The Drill Down on iTunes (Subscribe now!)
Add us on Stitcher!
The Drill Down on Facebook
The Drill Down on Twitter

Geeks Of Doom’s The Drill Down is a roundtable-style audio podcast where we discuss the most important issues of the week, in tech and on the web and how they affect us all.

Hosts are Geeks of Doom contributor Andrew Sorcini (Mr. BabyMan), marketing research analyst Dwayne De Freitas, and Box tech consultant Tosin Onafowokan. Occasionally joining them is Startup Digest CTO Christopher Burnor.

The Drill Down 331: A Call of Fire (preview)

amazon-fire-phoneThis week, Amazon unveils the 3D interface Fire Phone and launches Prime Music, Google wants to go to space and keep you healthy, Tesla gives its patents away, and drones that follow your every move…. all this and more….

See the full post here on Geeks of Doom!

Subscribe!

The Drill Down on iTunes (Subscribe now!)
Add us on Stitcher!
The Drill Down on Facebook
The Drill Down on Twitter

Geeks Of Doom’s The Drill Down is a roundtable-style audio podcast where we discuss the most important issues of the week, in tech and on the web and how they affect us all.

Hosts are Geeks of Doom contributor Andrew Sorcini (Mr. BabyMan), marketing research analyst Dwayne De Freitas, and Box tech consultant Tosin Onafowokan. Occasionally joining them is Startup Digest CTO Christopher Burnor.

The Drill Down 316: On My Last Optic Nerve (preview)

Optic-Nerve

This week, the British NSA (GCHQ) snoops on millions of webcams, Apple’s CarPlay, Google’s modular cellphone, Microsoft’s version of Siri, Facebook to launch drones, the selfie that broke Twitter, and much more.

See the full post here at Geeks of Doom!

Subscribe!

The Drill Down on iTunes (Subscribe now!)
Add us on Stitcher!
The Drill Down on Facebook
The Drill Down on Twitter

Geeks Of Doom’s The Drill Down is a roundtable-style audio podcast where we discuss the most important issues of the week, in tech and on the web and how they affect us all.

Hosts are Geeks of Doom contributor Andrew Sorcini (Mr. BabyMan), marketing research analyst Dwayne De Freitas, and Box tech consultant Tosin Onafowokan. Occasionally joining them is Startup Digest CTO Christopher Burnor.

The Drill Down 313: The Brief Rise and Fall of Flappy Bird (preview)

Flappy_Bird_Get_Ready_Game_Over
This week, Sony ditches the PC market, Comcast buys Time Warner Cable, Amazon’s ready to play games, GoPro goes for IPO, Google shows their true colors, ‘Flappy Bird’ gets its wings clipped, and more…

See the full post here on Geeks of Doom!

Subscribe!

The Drill Down on iTunes (Subscribe now!)
Add us on Stitcher!
The Drill Down on Facebook
The Drill Down on Twitter

Geeks Of Doom’s The Drill Down is a roundtable-style audio podcast where we discuss the most important issues of the week, in tech and on the web and how they affect us all.

Hosts are Geeks of Doom contributor Andrew Sorcini (Mr. BabyMan), marketing research analyst Dwayne De Freitas, and Box tech consultant Tosin Onafowokan. Occasionally joining them is Startup Digest CTO Christopher Burnor.

How Top Brands Used Content Marketing in 2013

van-damme-splits-volvo-trucks-w
The following is a guest post.

Content marketing is always evolving and brands that can constantly revamp themselves are the ones that stay afloat and even thrive. Unlike other forms of traditional marketing, content marketing is more volatile thanks to constant changes in search engines, social media platforms and consumer tastes that can completely derail existing content marketing strategies and campaigns. Your brand must be able to change its content marketing strategies and campaigns to keep up with changes in the world of marketing and gain an edge over your competitors. Continue reading

The Drill Down 305: Robots and Drones at the Door (preview)

amazon-prime-air
This week, the NSA tracks your cellphones and knows where you are, Americans boost Black Friday & Cyber Monday to record highs, and the future of commerce is in drones and robots, and it’s not that far off…

See the full post here at Geeks of Doom!

Subscribe!

The Drill Down on iTunes (Subscribe now!)
Add us on Stitcher!
The Drill Down on Facebook
The Drill Down on Twitter

Geeks Of Doom’s The Drill Down is a roundtable-style audio podcast where we discuss the most important issues of the week, in tech and on the web and how they affect us all.

Hosts are Geeks of Doom contributor Andrew Sorcini (Mr. BabyMan), marketing research analyst Dwayne De Freitas, and Box tech consultant Tosin Onafowokan. Occasionally joining them is Startup Digest CTO Christopher Burnor.